
Thomas Nast was a freelance journalist of American German decent in the 19th century. He later established the “Harper’s Weekly.” He seemed to be affiliated with Radical Republican ideology, with a blend of liberalism, progressive and nationalist tendencies. His cartoons portray him as a strong supporter for the Union government. He skillfully used allegory and melodrama in his cartoons to support the Republican Party; this will be proven when we analyze his piece titled “This is a White Man’s Government.”
“This is a White Man’s Government” was sketched in September 1868. The significance of the date in this sketch is that on April 9th, 1865, General Robert E Lee of the Confederacy surrenders to General Ulysses S. Grant of the Union Army. Lincoln was assassinated shortly after that leaving his Vice President Andrew Johnson to assume the office and finish the reconstruction era. In 1868, President Johnson was impeached by the Senate for dismissing Edwin Stanton, his Secretary of War. Earlier, Congress had passed the ‘Tenure of Office Act’ which serve to check and balance on the president’s appointment power.
There was tension between the White House and Congress due to differences in methods of approach as to how to go about innovating the South, and transitioning the rebel States into the Union. However, they agreed on forceful enforcement to ratify the “Reconstruction Amendments” which were the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments to the Constitution.
In this famous cartoon, Thomas Nast features members of the Democratic Party ravaging a Union Veteran who appeared to be Black. The man on the left is a caricature of an Irish American man, whose cap has the inscription ‘5 Points,’ referring to the New York City Irish Men who are often configured as mob. The ‘Five Points’ was part of the old Sixth Ward of the 19th Century New York (The New Yorker). It was the worst slum area habited by Irish immigrants and, later joined by freed Blacks fleeing the segregated South.
The Irish man on the left of the Cartoon is been portrayed as a beastly figure because, like the Blacks in the 19th century, Irish immigrants were not welcomed in most communities in the United States. The beastly caricature of the Irish man also portray him as angry, could be because of the competition for jobs between newly arrived Blacks from Southern plantations. It is also not surprising for the appearance and behavior of the Irish Caricature, during this juncture in American History, Irish men were been forcefully conscripted in the Union army to fight what they considered as a “Black man’s war” (New Yorker, October 1998).
The Man in the middle is been identified by the initial “NBF” which probably stands for Nathan Bedford Forrest, a former infantry General in the Confederate army (Henry. 2009). On his right jacket pocket, there is a badge identifying his army brigade, “Fort Pillow.” According to military historian, David J. Eicher, Fort Pillow marked one of the bleakest, saddest events of American military history. This is because; General Nathan Bedford executed Black prisoners of war that surrendered to him at the fort on April 12, 1864 (Eicher, p.657). On his belt buckle, there is the inscription of “C.S.A.” It represents the Confederate bonds, and its true meaning is the Confederate States Army.
The “Lost Cause” is a name given to an elite group that was trying to persuade Southerners to join the Union government against the Southern Confederacy, between 1861 to 1865 civil war (Gallagher, 2000). Those against the incorporation of the Confederacy into the Union government are labeled present day as “Old School” and during the civil war as “old fashion Chivalry” (Gallagher, 2000).
The caricature in the right seem to be a very wealthy man holding a stack of money that could be used to buy votes, or pay Confederate loyalists to manhandle Blacks. He is probably from 5th Avenue in New York, because his badge has the identification of being a 5th Avenue resident. His wallet has the writing “Capital Votes” which makes this writer believes he was buying votes. This was not the case in the South, Republicans especially Blacks are forced to vote Democrat without paying them a dime. A pistol and a couple of jabs will do the bribing for them to change their mind and cast a vote for the Democrats. The detailed of his clothes definitely distinguished him from the others, even without the stack of money in his hand; one could identify this man as being wealthy.
The background between the middle and left figure portrays a building in flames, titled “Colored Orphan Asylum.” The Colored Orphan Asylum was a place that house over 600 Black children’s, situated in 5th Avenue, New York. During the infamous riots in New York, July 1863, Irish immigrants attacked the Orphanage and destroyed the lives of several Black children. That was a contributing factor while the Irish man in the caricature had been published as a beast, due to the violent nature of the Irish immigrants (Harper’s weekly, August 1, 1863). A Black man is also hanging on an electric pole beside the Orphanage, emphasizing the horror during the riot. On the right is a school building for Black children which suited the description of the piece given on the “Report of the Board of Education for Freedmen, in 1864” on the Moodle website.
As already mentioned, the man on the ground seems to represent Black Union Veteran, trying to exercise his right to vote. The 15th amendment to the Constitution guaranteed the right of freed male slaves to vote. The man on the ground seem to have refused to accept bribe money to vote Democrat, thereby angered the rich man from 5th avenue and his Confederate pals , who were determined to teach him a lesson. The determination of the man on the ground to vote is clearly indicated by his resistance to terror, and his courage to exercise his franchise right to vote. Although he was on the ground, he still has a firm grip of the Union flag on his right hand. His left hand stretched towards the ballot box in defiance to complete his vote as he desired and not by the wish of any Confederate supporter.
The setting somehow conflicts the author’s statement earlier on about violence in the polling station to be practice only in the South, and not the North. Nast seems to suggest that if the Democrats failed to change Black vote by paying them, they will use force if necessary to disenfranchise them. They may exercise their franchise right to voting, but by voting contrary to their wish is tantamount to disenfranchising them.
Finally, it is very disappointing that Nast was very bias, concentrating only on the vices of the Democratic Party, instead of being impartial. There is no credibility in journalism if you can predict what the publisher is going to write. I wonder how his newspaper makes money if only read by Republicans. It’s like listening at present time to Rush Limburg’s show which so one sided that, it left very little room for Republican writers to defend his views.
Bibliographies
Gallagher, Mathew. “ Military Aspects of the captured of the Confederate Army.” The emancipation and its Consequences, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2001
Henry, Charles. “The Black Scholar,” Volume 39” (2009): 7-8. Print.
Institute for Research Center in African- American Studies, “The Political Orientation of Young African Americans” (New York: Columbia University, 2008).
The Chronicle of Higher Education: “Private Colleges” 1958. Web, 6 September, 58.
[
Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<http/>') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<a target='_blank' title='ImageShack - Image And Video Hosting' href='http://img294.imageshack.us/i/0568w500.jpg/'><img src='http://img294.imageshack.us/img294/1586/0568w500.jpg' border='0'/></a>
Thomas Nast was a freelance journalist of American German decent in the 19th century. He later established the “Harper’s Weekly.” He seemed to be affiliated with Radical Republican ideology, with a blend of liberalism, progressive and nationalist tendencies. His cartoons portray him as a strong supporter for the Union government. He skillfully used allegory and melodrama in his cartoons to support the Republican Party; this will be proven when we analyze his piece titled “This is a White Man’s Government.”
“This is a White Man’s Government” was sketched in September 1868. The significance of the date in this sketch is that on April 9th, 1865, General Robert E Lee of the Confederacy surrenders to General Ulysses S. Grant of the Union Army. Lincoln was assassinated shortly after that leaving his Vice President Andrew Johnson to assume the office and finish the reconstruction era. In 1868, President Johnson was impeached by the Senate for dismissing Edwin Stanton, his Secretary of War. Earlier, Congress had passed the ‘Tenure of Office Act’ which serve to check and balance on the president’s appointment power.
There was tension between the White House and Congress due to differences in methods of approach as to how to go about innovating the South, and transitioning the rebel States into the Union. However, they agreed on forceful enforcement to ratify the “Reconstruction Amendments” which were the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments to the Constitution.
In this famous cartoon, Thomas Nast features members of the Democratic Party ravaging a Union Veteran who appeared to be Black. The man on the left is a caricature of an Irish American man, whose cap has the inscription ‘5 Points,’ referring to the New York City Irish Men who are often configured as mob. The ‘Five Points’ was part of the old Sixth Ward of the 19th Century New York (The New Yorker). It was the worst slum area habited by Irish immigrants and, later joined by freed Blacks fleeing the segregated South.
The Irish man on the left of the Cartoon is been portrayed as a beastly figure because, like the Blacks in the 19th century, Irish immigrants were not welcomed in most communities in the United States. The beastly caricature of the Irish man also portray him as angry, could be because of the competition for jobs between newly arrived Blacks from Southern plantations. It is also not surprising for the appearance and behavior of the Irish Caricature, during this juncture in American History, Irish men were been forcefully conscripted in the Union army to fight what they considered as a “Black man’s war” (New Yorker, October 1998).
The Man in the middle is been identified by the initial “NBF” which probably stands for Nathan Bedford Forrest, a former infantry General in the Confederate army (Henry. 2009). On his right jacket pocket, there is a badge identifying his army brigade, “Fort Pillow.” According to military historian, David J. Eicher, Fort Pillow marked one of the bleakest, saddest events of American military history. This is because; General Nathan Bedford executed Black prisoners of war that surrendered to him at the fort on April 12, 1864 (Eicher, p.657). On his belt buckle, there is the inscription of “C.S.A.” It represents the Confederate bonds, and its true meaning is the Confederate States Army.
The “Lost Cause” is a name given to an elite group that was trying to persuade Southerners to join the Union government against the Southern Confederacy, between 1861 to 1865 civil war (Gallagher, 2000). Those against the incorporation of the Confederacy into the Union government are labeled present day as “Old School” and during the civil war as “old fashion Chivalry” (Gallagher, 2000).
The caricature in the right seem to be a very wealthy man holding a stack of money that could be used to buy votes, or pay Confederate loyalists to manhandle Blacks. He is probably from 5th Avenue in New York, because his badge has the identification of being a 5th Avenue resident. His wallet has the writing “Capital Votes” which makes this writer believes he was buying votes. This was not the case in the South, Republicans especially Blacks are forced to vote Democrat without paying them a dime. A pistol and a couple of jabs will do the bribing for them to change their mind and cast a vote for the Democrats. The detailed of his clothes definitely distinguished him from the others, even without the stack of money in his hand; one could identify this man as being wealthy.
The background between the middle and left figure portrays a building in flames, titled “Colored Orphan Asylum.” The Colored Orphan Asylum was a place that house over 600 Black children’s, situated in 5th Avenue, New York. During the infamous riots in New York, July 1863, Irish immigrants attacked the Orphanage and destroyed the lives of several Black children. That was a contributing factor while the Irish man in the caricature had been published as a beast, due to the violent nature of the Irish immigrants (Harper’s weekly, August 1, 1863). A Black man is also hanging on an electric pole beside the Orphanage, emphasizing the horror during the riot. On the right is a school building for Black children which suited the description of the piece given on the “Report of the Board of Education for Freedmen, in 1864” on the Moodle website.
As already mentioned, the man on the ground seems to represent Black Union Veteran, trying to exercise his right to vote. The 15th amendment to the Constitution guaranteed the right of freed male slaves to vote. The man on the ground seem to have refused to accept bribe money to vote Democrat, thereby angered the rich man from 5th avenue and his Confederate pals , who were determined to teach him a lesson. The determination of the man on the ground to vote is clearly indicated by his resistance to terror, and his courage to exercise his franchise right to vote. Although he was on the ground, he still has a firm grip of the Union flag on his right hand. His left hand stretched towards the ballot box in defiance to complete his vote as he desired and not by the wish of any Confederate supporter.
The setting somehow conflicts the author’s statement earlier on about violence in the polling station to be practice only in the South, and not the North. Nast seems to suggest that if the Democrats failed to change Black vote by paying them, they will use force if necessary to disenfranchise them. They may exercise their franchise right to voting, but by voting contrary to their wish is tantamount to disenfranchising them.
Finally, it is very disappointing that Nast was very bias, concentrating only on the vices of the Democratic Party, instead of being impartial. There is no credibility in journalism if you can predict what the publisher is going to write. I wonder how his newspaper makes money if only read by Republicans. It’s like listening at present time to Rush Limburg’s show which so one sided that, it left very little room for Republican writers to defend his views.
Bibliographies
Gallagher, Mathew. “ Military Aspects of the captured of the Confederate Army.” The emancipation and its Consequences, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2001
Henry, Charles. “The Black Scholar,” Volume 39” (2009): 7-8. Print.
Institute for Research Center in African- American Studies, “The Political Orientation of Young African Americans” (New York: Columbia University, 2008).
The Chronicle of Higher Education: “Private Colleges” 1958. Web, 6 September, 58. <http// chronicle.com/article/The-50K-Club-58-Private/48989/>
Gershon Bai-Lama Bangura
African Center For Transparency and Accountability (ACTA)
General Manager
Greencastle
USA